Skip to main content

LD9: The Story Knife

This week, Lucy faces that childhood dilemma of wanting to give generously while facing a budget that includes household flotsam that nobody wants. It's tough to inspire appreciation for a gift that no one misses when it disappears; like the dance festival, the gift must be infused with a new value. After foraging around the house, Lucy finds that several familiar outdoor elements have found their way indoors. Her resulting bounty: a tip of moose antler, a tuft of dog fur, and a piece of tundra cotton.

We never really know whether Lucy simply likes the objects, or whether she grasps their import to an older Yup'ik subsistence lifestyle. The dog fur, of course, is a side effect of relying on huskies for transportation and/or companionship. The moose antler would signify a great achievement in furnishing many materials for the subsistence lifestyle. A moose might be the subsistence equivalent of a walking Target store.

The tundra cotton, however, I'm not sure of. I'm aware that in a pinch, some Yup'ik people would stuff grass and plants inside their mukluks as insulation, and tundra cotton looks like a more welcoming plant than most others. Otherwise, I can't find any direct online references to uses of tundra cotton. Yup'ik women did weave, but usually the material came from the fur of musk-ox collected from where it accumulated on shrubbery. Any thoughts or ideas on the use of tundra cotton are welcome.

You've seen Lucy's family's collection of gifts, a mixture of the contemporary and traditional. Decades ago, handmade gifts might have included: food, skins and furs, dolls, knit goods, carvings, other tools, basketry woven from grass, parkas, mukluks, or qayaks. While I was researching Yup'ik crafts, I learned about the story knife, which may or may not have been gifted at potlatches. It seems that women passed it down through families, as women hold a special place as storytellers within Yup'ik culture. The knife is carved from ivory and used to sketch and inscribe pictures in the ground while telling a story. I can't help but make comparisons to my Wacom stylus, which is not made of ivory, but still plenty of fun.

I asked the author, Deb Vanasse, why she chose the three elements to represent Lucy's gift. She responded that she chose them more for their emotional resonance than for their practical importance, "because each would have a story behind it." Vanasse added, "In truth, the book is as much about Lucy’s gift as her dance; in essence, the dance is her gift, much as the dancing tradition is a gift both to and from the Yup’ik culture."

Her comment reminded me that drawing the three objects in this illustration was a good deal simpler than drawing Lucy's "larger" gift will be. On that note, I'm headed back to my story knife.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Work from Home

  The reference for this piece is a known work of fine art: a photograph by Peter Mitchell, a lorry driver who traversed West Yorkshire and occasionally snapped photos. The piece is titled Eric Massheder, Leeds, (1975) . Eric is the man in the doorway, a drippings refinery worker who posed in his home, adjacent (really, attached) to the refinery where he worked for 12 years. Eric woke up in his home in the morning, walked one room (or so) over, and began his shift. I have changed and omitted a few details for the sake of composition as usual. I've now been working from home for about four years, and I make a similar commute without stepping outdoors. My house even resembles Eric's a bit, though there's no factory nearby. I enter my workplace by transferring a USB cable, which joins all of my input and output devices from my personal computer to my work laptop. I stoop under my desk to make the transfer, so possibly a similar amount of exercise is involved—the digital equiva...

LD3: Neutral Coloration

My third illustration for Lucy's Dance treats the delicate topic of the missionaries who visited Stebbins in the late 1920's and stopped the Curukaq festival . . . or rather, tamed it into hiatus. A Jesuit missionary, Fr. Martin Lonneaux, overlooking the support-system of the Yup'ik community, perceived that the gift-giving portion of the festival was costly enough that it left several Yup'ik families destitute. Lonneaux concocted a watered-down version of the potlatch that would involve smaller, church-supplied gifts, but in the process amputated the festive spirit of the festival such that his "pretend kassiyuq " never caught on. For further details, see Stebbins Dance Festival (xxiv). The wording in Lucy's Dance focuses neutrally on the cultural misunderstanding. It would have been easy to use powerfully-charged language when summarizing this cultural loss. From what little I can find about him, Fr. Lonneaux, SJ seems to have been a relatively toler...

Argument from Final Consequences, feat. Jack White

In the SG definition, "Such arguments (also called teleological) are based on a reversal of cause and effect, because they argue that something is caused by the ultimate effect that it has, or purpose that is serves." As the White Stripes put it in their song, " Effect and Cause ": "first comes an action, and then a reaction, which you can't switch around for your own satisfaction." Another fitting example from the song: "if you're headed for the grave, don't blame the hearse." I've decided to be a bit abstract in my interpretation of the fallacy. Normally, the negative space , or the space around the snail shape, is an effect of the snail. In this drawing, I have shifted the negative space to the foreground, allowing it to cause a shadow. I have effectively cut out the negative space and placed in front of a telescope. The fallacy is sometimes called the "teleological" (end/purpose) fallacy because it makes effects, o...